Thanks everyone - usually i'm in a 5 or 6mm drylock/flashbomb for the season but was curious to try something new out with the sale. I'm in the water alot and tend to blow through suits pretty quickly - lucky if i get two seasons at best on the thick ones.Bought one on the same deal. Great suit for PNW as stated. It's a little stiff compared to a sponge like O'neill. Much better quality though, and holds it temp rating for a long time, unlike previous mentioned sponge that's only good for a few months.
NY winter? No way. You'll freeze. I'd want a 6/5 Billabong or Xcell.
I do have a needs 4/3 hooded that works really well through the end of December and v early spring if anyones curious.