this is my first xtr I’ve surfed since the foam was 6, iirc. i think the last one I owned was 4, so it’s been a while... back when they used to still have little pin holes and sounded almost like tuflite when they’d smack the water.XTR feels like it's something in-between poly and EPS. However, the short stature of this board does not do you any favors when trying to cut through lump and bump.
my only complaint thus far is that xtr carries no momentum compared to poly paddling around.
mine is 6” under my height and about a liter and a half more than my short boar vol.Sizing is subjective and based on skill level, the region you surf, ect, but you can size these things all over the place and they still work. Probably best to target something a couple inches less than your height.
I'm 5'9 and 160. My first one was 4'10. My current one is a 5'1. This upcoming order will be a 5'5. Same volume as my hpsb but you can up the volume a couple liters if you want.
I don’t think adding foam would make it a better paddler at this length. It’s awkward to paddle a door, I don’t know a bigger door helps, lol. I don’t think shorter/wider does favors in this regard either.
up surging, I think it’s sized perfectly for me.