It erodes public trust and is actually counterproductive.
20 people died in the debris flow in Montecito due in large part to the erosion of public trust, coupled with the incompetent way in which people were told to evacuate to be “safe” from a
rainstorm.
The area had been under an evacuation order for several weeks due to the Thomas fire. This order was in place for way too long
after the threat of fire to the area had ceased to exist. It was, if memory serves, about two full weeks too long. People eventually got so pissed off that the evac order was lifted due to the impending mass non-compliance that brewing. My old next door neighbor is very high up the food chain at SBFD - very high up. He was livid with the sheriff department’s refusal to allow residents back into their homes in Cito and Mission Canyon areas.
They had the national guard blocking roads into these areas.
My father-in-law who is a Mission Canyon resident stayed with us for what amounted to about a month because he was not allowed back into his house. Our rental unit had two families from Cito staying in it - free of charge btw - for that time. We had 12 people staying on our property - 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms total - during that time so we had a good feel for the general attitudes that were formed.
The fire evacuation order was finally lifted and people went home.
It was a few
days later that the rain storm hit. Another evacuation order was issued for Montecito, rather hastily, and they used the
same maps used for fire evacuations for the rain evacuations.
Pretty much everyone ignored the order. A crazy downpour occurred in a very isolated area that had just had all of it’s vegetation replaced with ash and charcoal right above Montecito and the ensuing debris flow killed 20 people, including a friend of mine.
Now they’re fighting their last war every time it rains, a war that they lost the first time around.
At least now they only evacuate the specific areas that are at least theoretically threatened.
The funny thing is that the conditions that precipitated that debris flow were very specific and the key component - a burned out vegetation free front country coupled with debris filled creeks - no longer exists.
Vegetation is back, creeks are now cleared regularly and giant debris basins have been constructed.
Oh and it stopped raining too.