Long Fish vs Mid Length

trifish

Billy Hamilton status
Sep 23, 2009
1,384
3,897
113
Shred City
Not sure mine is a long fish....maybe just a longer fish, but my 6'2" xtr moonstone is my fav board. Tons of drive, speed, projection, and loves being on rail. Maybe not a fair comparison to a more traditional long fish some guys make. It has a lot of performance even with keels. Liked it so much I have a longer one on order.

Had a 6'3" xtr Townsend round pin a while back. In comparison to the moonstone you could feel extra hold off the tail and more control on bigger days. Maybe a bit more pivot overall. It felt a bit less exciting in a way compared to the ms and I let it go. Maybe the slower/safer feeling and i've been enjoying fast/drivey boards lately.

I picked up a 6'8" xtr Townsend later on and got it with a diamond tail in hopes of making it more playful this time. Faster and more snappy for sure with the way it releases compared to the rp I had. Overall more fun for me. You give up a little upper end, but seems more versatile in average conditions with the little wider tail and less of the feel of the pin dragging. If I was only going to surf it on the biggest days I would go with the rp, otherwise I like the dt more in everything else.

Last one was a 6'8" Sakal Sabre in pu I picked up more recently. Probably only have 6 surfs on it. First impressions.... a good bit less performance than my 6'8" Townsend. It is nearly an inch wider/more foam/heavier than xtr so i expected it. You feel the weight and surf it slower. Catches waves extremely well though and paddles into them great. Easier than all the boards in my quiver I think. Has more rocker in the nose than my townsend with 1/4 less in the tail and has channels. It was designed for keels and feels drivey/fast down the line. I've had some turns on it that felt good when getting my backfoot in the right spot but it kinda feels like it wants to just go and not be forced vertical too much. You can shuffle your feet all around and it will still go, just need to get back if you really want to swing it. I'm enjoying it lately when i want to surf more mellow or catch a lot of waves when its busy.
 

Oceanslide

Kelly Slater status
Mar 5, 2008
9,708
2,354
113
Oceanside, CA
View attachment 140665

View attachment 140666

Because I know how much you all love my home decor shots.

Plus the killer pitbull should offend/terrify somebody, so there's that.

Is what it is.
I love when you go off on design threads.
Some of the best posts from peeps who actually know what they’re talking about. Please don’t leave, like many of your kind (ilk? stature?) have.
 

20W-50 and blood

Duke status
Feb 4, 2004
24,979
4,095
113
SOCAL
Visit site
I love when you go off on design threads.
Some of the best posts from peeps who actually know what they’re talking about. Please don’t leave, like many of your kind (ilk? stature?) have.
i, for the record...hate sharky for all the porn he posts that i cant touch....or leave sticky pages too? or really touch? bastard.

that thing looks KILER
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Sharky

One-Off

Tom Curren status
Jul 28, 2005
14,270
10,473
113
33.8N - 118.4W
I'll take some pictures in a few minutes. Let me get some coffee in me. The board was kind of a journey. I almost never do anything normal/simple because, that's the way I am I suppose. That and I have literally thousands of board files and I'm fairly good with the design software. Can't ever leave good enough alone.

But yeah, COVID board. Everyone on mid lengths. Or worse. Longboards. So WTF. I could have taken an Alpha Omega and just scaled it up to 7'2". That was too easy. So I took a Russ Short file that was a 7'2". I pretty much just pushed the tail width out until I got it where I thought I wanted it. I don't remember what my numbers were. But then after I pushed the tail out, with the stock overall width, I didn't like the outline. Too straight. So I started pushing the overall width out. I got it to 21 3/4 and liked the outline better. In retrospect I should have pushed it to 22. But I had a barrier in my head re that width, so I left it. Then, considering it was going to be a twin fin, I dropped the tail rocker a touch and for added control Malcolm decided to hand shape some deeper concave into the board.

Then I got stupid(er). I ran into these Tyler Warren marine ply fins with an 80/20 foil on them, pulled some numbers out of my head for placement and had them glassed on using my dims. The fins kind of just showed up for me, (it was easy) and they looked sexy. And took the board surfing.

And it was a dog. It felt like driving with the hand brake on. I just could NOT make the board go. The board totally ruined a very rare almost empty minus tide point break session at a favorite point. It still makes me cringe. I got back to the shop and it wasn't a surfboard as far as I was concerned. And it had Malcolm's name on it. I came close to taking a chain saw to it because it was my retarded idea. But after I cooled down and went over the design file, I came to the conclusion that there was nothing I had done to the design file that would have turned a proven file into a dog. It HAD to be the fins. I still came close to destroying it and starting over, but I let it sit. Professional curiosity overcame me and I decided to try and fix it. Had someone grind the glass ons off. Moved the fins up from the tail and further out towards the rail. Futures with the Hobie keels. Single foil fins. And the hand brake came off. The board did what I figured it should do. Fast smooth turns, generated speed easily, caught waves easily, and was just a smooth handling board.

Then Malcom gave me some True Ames twins to try in it. With the twins in it, you could tighten the arc of the turns, push a little tail slide into it when you wanted and it became closer to a HP type shortboard. People kept asking me how long the board was because they were kind of shocked at the turns I could push it through. For an increasingly aging surfer. It's all relative. Then Allan Gibbons gave me a set of twin fins. A little more fin. The feeling now was almost like surfing a step up/gun board in smaller waves with a hint more release when you weighted forward a bit and pushed it in the right spot. For surfers who are old enough to remember meat and potato North Shore "shortboards" in the 7'3" to 7'6" range, you'd get it easily. You could still surf it fairly progressively by say early 80's standards and you still had the paddle power.

So the board is pretty much all good after being seconds from the chainsaw. Once I had it where I wanted it, I pretty much stopped surfing it. Because that's what I do. I get bored with a board and move on. It's great for your surfing. You never ride anything long enough to get it down for more than a session or two and then move on. Brilliant. Oh well. Pictures in a minute.

But the difference in how that board rode with the fins moved/etc. was shocking. Fins are still difficult for me to understand at times. This is where I miss Greg Griffin. RIP old man.
Great post. "For an increasingly aging surfer, it's all relative." is my new signature line. :jamon:
 

Maz

Michael Peterson status
May 18, 2004
3,091
4,639
113
Innzid
Was out at the middle point this afternoon, cruising on a big board and trying to get my confidence back after my hamstring injury. Only other guy out the back was Tom Lowe on a 7'0 Christensen Long Fish and he was surfing so well, especially considering how fcuked up he got at Teahupoo. Salt of the earth fella too.

Made me want to give a Long Fish a go.
 

Turtle71

Nep status
Jan 19, 2010
664
15
18
53
NE FL
Just bought a basically brand new 7'4" Seaside and beyond because it was dirt cheap. I assume cheap since it's no longer flavour of the month for the Machado fan club so will see how that goes.
So how is it going with the Seaside and beyond? Curious to see what you think as I am also intrigued with the 7'0" Outlier you seem to be fond of. Debating between these two and a Harley Ingleby Moe to help with the increasing crowds in northeast Florida. Might be fun to play around with for winter as well.
 
Last edited:

Retropete

Phil Edwards status
Jan 20, 2006
6,042
4,582
113
Sunny Coast Qld Australia
So how is it going with the Seaside and beyond? Curious to see what you think as I am also intrigued with the 7'0" Outlier you seem to be fond of. Debating between these two and a Harley Ingleby Moe to help with the increasing crowds in northeast Florida. Might be fun to play around with for winter as well.
The SS&B was sold on after a few surfs. I didn't like having to surf it right off the tail in turns. I'm no fan of the Moe. Pushes water when paddling and I gives me sore shoulders as a result. Goes ok on a wave but doesn't have the wow factor that makes me want to keep boards.
 

Turtle71

Nep status
Jan 19, 2010
664
15
18
53
NE FL
The SS&B was sold on after a few surfs. I didn't like having to surf it right off the tail in turns. I'm no fan of the Moe. Pushes water when paddling and I gives me sore shoulders as a result. Goes ok on a wave but doesn't have the wow factor that makes me want to keep boards.
Thanks for the info. So the Outlier is still the one that outshines the others you have tried? Also saw a Stewart you had posted in the midlength thread. Did you sell that one as well?
 

JaM71

OTF status
Jul 12, 2013
180
66
28
GC, Australia
@Turtle71 I highly recommend the 7-oh outlier for small waves, if it's junky and weak, even better. It can still go in good waves, but why bother when you have good wave boards handy.

It feels like a hybrid of a stubby, a fish and a mini simmons. Really fast in weak/soft waves and turns beautifully. A little bit different to a single fin as it's a little more back foot oriented
 

Havoc

Rabbitt Bartholomew status
May 23, 2016
7,837
12,520
113
in da hood next to paradise
I'll take some pictures in a few minutes. Let me get some coffee in me. The board was kind of a journey. I almost never do anything normal/simple because, that's the way I am I suppose. That and I have literally thousands of board files and I'm fairly good with the design software. Can't ever leave good enough alone.

But yeah, COVID board. Everyone on mid lengths. Or worse. Longboards. So WTF. I could have taken an Alpha Omega and just scaled it up to 7'2". That was too easy. So I took a Russ Short file that was a 7'2". I pretty much just pushed the tail width out until I got it where I thought I wanted it. I don't remember what my numbers were. But then after I pushed the tail out, with the stock overall width, I didn't like the outline. Too straight. So I started pushing the overall width out. I got it to 21 3/4 and liked the outline better. In retrospect I should have pushed it to 22. But I had a barrier in my head re that width, so I left it. Then, considering it was going to be a twin fin, I dropped the tail rocker a touch and for added control Malcolm decided to hand shape some deeper concave into the board.

Then I got stupid(er). I ran into these Tyler Warren marine ply fins with an 80/20 foil on them, pulled some numbers out of my head for placement and had them glassed on using my dims. The fins kind of just showed up for me, (it was easy) and they looked sexy. And took the board surfing.

And it was a dog. It felt like driving with the hand brake on. I just could NOT make the board go. The board totally ruined a very rare almost empty minus tide point break session at a favorite point. It still makes me cringe. I got back to the shop and it wasn't a surfboard as far as I was concerned. And it had Malcolm's name on it. I came close to taking a chain saw to it because it was my retarded idea. But after I cooled down and went over the design file, I came to the conclusion that there was nothing I had done to the design file that would have turned a proven file into a dog. It HAD to be the fins. I still came close to destroying it and starting over, but I let it sit. Professional curiosity overcame me and I decided to try and fix it. Had someone grind the glass ons off. Moved the fins up from the tail and further out towards the rail. Futures with the Hobie keels. Single foil fins. And the hand brake came off. The board did what I figured it should do. Fast smooth turns, generated speed easily, caught waves easily, and was just a smooth handling board.

Then Malcom gave me some True Ames twins to try in it. With the twins in it, you could tighten the arc of the turns, push a little tail slide into it when you wanted and it became closer to a HP type shortboard. People kept asking me how long the board was because they were kind of shocked at the turns I could push it through. For an increasingly aging surfer. It's all relative. Then Allan Gibbons gave me a set of twin fins. A little more fin. The feeling now was almost like surfing a step up/gun board in smaller waves with a hint more release when you weighted forward a bit and pushed it in the right spot. For surfers who are old enough to remember meat and potato North Shore "shortboards" in the 7'3" to 7'6" range, you'd get it easily. You could still surf it fairly progressively by say early 80's standards and you still had the paddle power.

So the board is pretty much all good after being seconds from the chainsaw. Once I had it where I wanted it, I pretty much stopped surfing it. Because that's what I do. I get bored with a board and move on. It's great for your surfing. You never ride anything long enough to get it down for more than a session or two and then move on. Brilliant. Oh well. Pictures in a minute.

But the difference in how that board rode with the fins moved/etc. was shocking. Fins are still difficult for me to understand at times. This is where I miss Greg Griffin. RIP old man.
so fins forward made a big difference. Also switching to uprights.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sharky

Retropete

Phil Edwards status
Jan 20, 2006
6,042
4,582
113
Sunny Coast Qld Australia
Thanks for the info. So the Outlier is still the one that outshines the others you have tried? Also saw a Stewart you had posted in the midlength thread. Did you sell that one as well?
Sold the Stewart to part fund the second purchase of the Outlier 7'er. My first one went to JaM71.
The Stewart is a very fun board to surf and works well in waist high to overhead, clean conditions and then it's wide nose becomes a liability in duckdiving when waves are larger.
The Outlier works at its best in the high tide, flatter faced clean waves and when its dis jointed and junky its connects the pockets of energy with all its planing area with consummate ease.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Turtle71

Retropete

Phil Edwards status
Jan 20, 2006
6,042
4,582
113
Sunny Coast Qld Australia
Joel Fitz IMO makes the only “mid lengths“ that look like they rock, hard. I’d still have a hard time riding anything retro over 6’6” unless it was gunny.

Re-visiting this and Imho you'd be hard pressed to find a "mid length" in the current crop that I am aware of that could outperform a Lost crowd killer in good head high plus, hollow waves where steep enough take offs prove problematic for wider and lowered rockered noses. Then tight turns in the pocket rather than out on the face would also be challenging for the current crop due to their lower tail rocker when compared to the crowd killer. I'd include boards like the Tolhurst Mid 6 (which I've ridden extensively) Pyzel mid life crisis and Chilli mid strength in the more performance end of the "mid length" catergory where the boards are commonly ridden in the 6'10" and longer lengths.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Aruka

jwd

Nov 24, 2004
97
53
18
Re-visiting this and Imho you'd be hard pressed to find a "mid length" in the current crop that I am aware of that could outperform a Lost crowd killer in good head high plus, hollow waves where steep enough take offs prove problematic for wider and lowered rockered noses. Then tight turns in the pocket rather than out on the face would also be challenging for the current crop due to their lower tail rocker when compared to the crowd killer. I'd include boards like the Tolhurst Mid 6 (which I've ridden extensively) Pyzel mid life crisis and Chilli mid strength in the more performance end of the "mid length" catergory where the boards are commonly ridden in the 6'10" and longer lengths.
Interesting thought. I figured the mid strength would be comparable if not more versatile than the crowd killer.