This thread highlights that we should be considering a ban on surfboards in traditional foil spots. Haha, I jest.
Seems to me that foiling is now taking on much of the hate that SUP got years ago, just now it's "Blame Kai" instead of "Blame Laird". But I think foiling is probably overall safer to others than SUP, despite the high speed sword/guillotine below us. The reason being foiling is really, really hard to learn, takes mega commitment to even get intermediate at it. Whereas SUP is so popular because of how easy it is. It may take someone years to get half decent on a shortboard, but you can catch waves on a SUP literally your first session. So it's all too easy for the lineup to be full of SUPs who can technically surf but really have no idea about safety or etiquette.
From what I've seen, foiling attracts an older demographic (expensive toys), maybe more thoughtful (nerdy techies) and hopefully more self-aware (willing to doggedly pursue this challenge). That reduces the likelihood of them being complete idiots in a crowded surfing line up. However, there's still the risk of the idiot factor ... and the bans at Bondi and in France show what will happen if these foils are considered a danger to others.
Similar to what's happened in the kiting community, the key to avoiding bans is self-policing. If you see people doing dumb s**t that threatens access, have to call them on it. That includes online: these instragram warriors with videos of them weaving around surfers, that's not smart.
Signed, Mr. Bob Loblaw