The closures and social distancing were as a result of information learned from the 1918 pandemic. Historians noted lower rates of infection in cities that cancelled parades, etc. It’s not science, really. It’s crude, but better than nothing.
The protests are partisan and fomented by right wing talk radio and Fox News related organizations.
Like a tidal wave, there is absolutely no way to stop an infectious pandemic.
All life forms have evolved together over billions of years. Viruses, mammals et al each evolve a different strain, a different defense through each generational cycle.
But the dance must be performed to determine the winners & losers. The original shutdown was an attempt to avoid a catastrophic initial wave that could have collapsed the health care system.
Thats it; not avoiding nor eliminating an eventual 60-70% infection rate. So the key is to push the time period when everyone will eventually be infected to the longer days of spring/summer.
Any further attempts at delaying the inevitable, immutable laws of nature are self defeating. Worse, they corode and corrupt the very elements of civilization that can provide the necessary support as the pandemic works its way through the population.
Everyone in any position of authority knows this. So the different approaches reflect regional/voter political calculus.
Knowing this, smart money goes long in fundamentals in red states, and gets the fvck out of blues.
Calif is a mixed bag due to its size/diversity. It wont perform as well as FL or TX, but thank doG its not HI.
That place is gonna burn.