I am searching for a feeling. Each board I ride has helped my surfing. Keep what works, dump what doesnt. I see an improvement in my surfing over the past 2 years (and i've been told that) so i think what im doing is working.A good shape is a good shape. I ride a good board til the death, then I order another of the same.
Because I surf a lot and I'm lucky to live near the beach I go through a lot more boards than most people. Once or twice a year I'll play with something new in the daily driver or good waves board genre.
But ultimately I tend to stick with old standbys. I don't like to play around much because I like to be very familiar with or dialed on a board. This allows me to take full advantage of each session.
There's nothing worse than a day of good waves on a board I just don't click with when I know there's a board sitting at home that would have worked great.
Generally I have a quiver to fill specific needs.
Groveler, daily driver, good waves board, big waves board.
I think it's fun to have a board dialed and I'm stoked when I'm taking full advantage of the conditions.
You live close to an hour from the beach (as I always say a really do admire your dedication) yet buy more boards in a year than most people buy in 10 years - probably even more boards than some pros go through in a year. There is no way you are getting all those boards dialed and thus you're probably missing a lot of opportunity in your surfing.
Quite honestly with as many boards as you rotate through my surfing would be completely confused and my ability would probably suffer.
Not all my boards are new ones. I've only bought about 4 new boards this year. I demo boards when i can. I also have boards that are over 2 years old that i know work.