I remember getting really fun, small waves at one of those turn off spots between Haliewa and everywhere else when I was a kid. One of those spots with some bouldery rocks on the inside, lefts on one side, rights on the other. I don't know which one it was.
I've been to Hawaii 3 times. But I've never had a good surf in Hawaii.
To be fair, none of those trips were "surf trips"
1) The first, I was 14, mostly riding longboards. Haleiwa had waves did NOT look fun for me. Surfed Bowls, or near Bowls. I guess that was ok.
2) The second time I went for work and my back was fucked. Surfed Makaha once, small. It got bigger and my back was wrecked. Surfed Sunset Point. It was small and still intimidating. I've never gotten used to staring at the reef. Flew to Kauai to visit a friend and surfed small waves.
3) The third time it was August and I was with my ex. I don't think I surfed.
I wish I would've gone with more of a surf focus in my youth