Caity Simmers, Stud or Dud?

ReForest

Miki Dora status
Oct 7, 2020
3,932
5,566
113
Caity is better than Bettylou.

Not taking the spot last year was the best thing she could have done. She’s significantly better now and mentally way more mature. I don’t expect top 3 next year but top 5 might be in the cards.
Idk about that. Caity might have better flow but Bettylou has been looking on fire!! She has some massive turns on her insta.
 
  • Like
Reactions: vanrysss

Bob Dobbalina

Miki Dora status
Feb 23, 2016
4,930
5,438
113
She rips.
She'll stay on tour.
She's not winning a title yet.
She has some great technique, but she still looks like she's swinging around a board that is too big for her sometimes, leaving her looking a little Conologueish.
She surfing still looks "small". She's On rail, frees the tail, hits the lip, all with proficiency. But you can't win a world title if you can't fan a frontside carve that makes the jaws drop. Cal it regressive all you want, it's just the way it is.

It'll be interesting to see how her surfing changes when she hits the next few growth spurts. It hits the female surfers harder than the men. She's due.


Dud? No
Imminent multiple world titles? No
She'll have to continue to improve.
She'l need to get off the Borsts and Learn to Rip coaching program to stay in the A league.
 

StuAzole

Duke status
Jan 22, 2016
30,199
11,145
113
She rips.
She'll stay on tour.
She's not winning a title yet.
She has some great technique, but she still looks like she's swinging around a board that is too big for her sometimes, leaving her looking a little Conologueish.
She surfing still looks "small". She's On rail, frees the tail, hits the lip, all with proficiency. But you can't win a world title if you can't fan a frontside carve that makes the jaws drop. Cal it regressive all you want, it's just the way it is.

It'll be interesting to see how her surfing changes when she hits the next few growth spurts. It hits the female surfers harder than the men. She's due.


Dud? No
Imminent multiple world titles? No
She'll have to continue to improve.
She'l need to get off the Borsts and Learn to Rip coaching program to stay in the A league.
I know nothing about lots of things, but I know this topic.

She’s already beaten pretty much everyone on tour already. While she doesn’t have Caroline or Lakey power, they can’t touch her air/release game.

Her airs will win events.

A close mentor of Carissa’s told me Caity has perhaps the best barrel riding technique he’s ever seen on the ladies side. It won’t surprise me if she wins JBay next year.

Like I said, not top 3 next year but probably top 5. WT in 3 years or less.
 

StuAzole

Duke status
Jan 22, 2016
30,199
11,145
113
Idk about that. Caity might have better flow but Bettylou has been looking on fire!! She has some massive turns on her insta.
She rips. And has power. She’s just not as good all around. She could still win a title one day though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ReForest

Bob Dobbalina

Miki Dora status
Feb 23, 2016
4,930
5,438
113
I know nothing about lots of things, but I know this topic.

She’s already beaten pretty much everyone on tour already. While she doesn’t have Caroline or Lakey power, they can’t touch her air/release game.

Her airs will win events.

A close mentor of Carissa’s told me Caity has perhaps the best barrel riding technique he’s ever seen on the ladies side. It won’t surprise me if she wins JBay next year.

Like I said, not top 3 next year but probably top 5. WT in 3 years or less.

She's got a lot going for her. I hope she grows into all of it.
 

ReForest

Miki Dora status
Oct 7, 2020
3,932
5,566
113
She rips. And has power. She’s just not as good all around. She could still win a title one day though.
Yeah... she needs to improve on some things. But her turns are very very good!

You're right about Caity's air game. She's got those down pretty solid. I never thought about her barrel riding technique, but I guess it is pretty good. I saw her catch barrel after barrel at the pier one day. She actually burned me pretty good on a wave that i had perfect positioning. She's a frother. It will be interesting to see how she does on tour.

If she starts now and keeps on course, she could have the same opportunity Slater had. I think he started competing at her age right?
 

casa_mugrienta

Duke status
Apr 13, 2008
45,261
20,070
113
Petak Island
She rips.
She'll stay on tour.
She's not winning a title yet.
She has some great technique, but she still looks like she's swinging around a board that is too big for her sometimes, leaving her looking a little Conologueish.
She surfing still looks "small". She's On rail, frees the tail, hits the lip, all with proficiency. But you can't win a world title if you can't fan a frontside carve that makes the jaws drop. Cal it regressive all you want, it's just the way it is.

It'll be interesting to see how her surfing changes when she hits the next few growth spurts. It hits the female surfers harder than the men. She's due.


Dud? No
Imminent multiple world titles? No
She'll have to continue to improve.
She'l need to get off the Borsts and Learn to Rip coaching program to stay in the A league.
Agree.

The only way her world title is imminent is by slipping through.
 

ReForest

Miki Dora status
Oct 7, 2020
3,932
5,566
113
Her DOB is October 2005.
Slater won his first title at 20 yo. Caity has until 2024 to win a title and beat Slaters record. :oops:
 

ReForest

Miki Dora status
Oct 7, 2020
3,932
5,566
113
Are you serious?

Plenty of surfers better than her have, and do call Oceanside home.
Name a surfer that has come out oside that made it on tour and had title wins?
Mike Lambresi and Chuy Reyna are the first ones to come to mind but not as young as Caity.
 

freeride76

Miki Dora status
Dec 31, 2009
3,785
4,908
113
Lennox Head.
Her turns aren't small.

I saw her surf in person at Snapper in May, unruly OH surf.

For a little ranga, her turns were impressive, and she's got plenty of variety in the top turn repertoire- which judges love.

Her problem will be the same one facing all rookies, male or female.

Pipe/Sunset/Portugal/Bells/Margies then a mid-year cut.

They are not easy waves for rookies to do well at.

Couple of bad heats and it's back to the CS.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Aruka

casa_mugrienta

Duke status
Apr 13, 2008
45,261
20,070
113
Petak Island
Name a surfer that has come out oside that made it on tour and had title wins?
Mike Lambresi and Chuy Reyna are the first ones to come to mind but not as young as Caity.
I was responding to you saying she might be the best surfer to ever come out of O'side. She's not, and probably won't be.
 

Bob Dobbalina

Miki Dora status
Feb 23, 2016
4,930
5,438
113
A few of you have not watched the 2 girls who have dominated the Tour for the last 10 years and it shows.